Update: Jonas Brothers keffiyehs generate internet controversy
July 17th, 2008 . by MartyBy way of an update to yesterday’s observation about Disney’s popular Jonas Brothers boy band, apparently the web has picked up on this story in strange ways. On the one hand, Shawarma Mayor very generously linked to me and added his own well-reasoned thoughts on the matter. Sadly, though, he has been attacked (Fark.com) from all sides of the pop-culture media, and has issued his own eloquent update today. I agree with his points completely, so let me just quote him:
Was it a keffiya? Maybe not, but perhaps fark readers should ask themselves why are they attracted to reading about it? Yea, I know the answer – Jonas Brothers are pop stars. I stumbled into something explosive, pop and politics…..
Now to the keffiya point – I’m not going to argue in favor or against it. For some it might not be understood how a garment can be offensive, so google it and read Debbie Schlussel’s or Michel Malkin’s point of view on the subject. It should be disturbing to you if something that is offensive to many becomes very popular and those who wear it are simply clueless as to why.
I will not and would not call a person a supporter of terrorism just because he wore something, especially not when he doesn’t know what it means. I will never fault an Arab for wearing what is obviously rooted in his culture and means a lot more to him than what it has turned out to symbolize in the latest few decades. But try to grasp this point; making a kefiye a popular and acceptable western attire is disturbing to many. If you don’t respect their opinion – at least acknowledge their sensitivity.
Let me just add - as I’ve said on this blog before - that it’s one thing for Meghan McCain to inadvertently wear a keffiyeh once or twice in public. But from what I hear from my cohorts on the campaign team, John McCain has wisely counseled his daughter, and you won’t be seeing her wear it again. The difference here is that Disney is proudly exploiting the poor fashion choices of these presumptively talented young kids, even after the Rachael Ray controversy came and went. The imagineers at Disney should know better.
Of course, like Shawarma Mayor, my principle bailiwick is in the realm of politics, not pop culture. Apologies to him for having to take the brunt of the untoward comments, so if you must comment about this matter, please feel free to have your say here.
[…] July 17th: This post has apparently created quite the uproar. See today’s post for […]
[…] not reading too much into this, but in the course of responding to media requests regarding the Jonas Brothers keffiyeh controversy, one of my interns alerted me to a story in the Indian press that revealed that Barack […]
[…] that’s a partisan question, isn’t it? Yeah, some partisan folks, like Martin Eisenstadt, think that the musical choices of Barack Obama’s daughters is a strong reason to vote […]
So, by “attacked” you mean “dismissed” by Fark?
I wasn’t aware that scarves were only worn by folks from the Middle East. It’s an interesting take, and perhaps folks don’t enjoy being dismissed as irrelevant, but that’s hardly an attack.
Drumming up extra traffic is fine, but I think you might be better served by not trying to bait folks–especially with false trails like this. You might want to re-read that Fark thread again.
I love the Jonas Brothers and i do believe that any of this talk about them being terrorists just because they wear a certain type of scarf is just ridiculous. I hate it when people make up rumours ! LOVE JONAS BROTHERS ! DO NOT LISTEN TO ANY RUMOURS! THEY’RE NOT TRUE!!!
JONAS BROTHERS RULE !!!!!!!